Valentine’s Cookies ~ Cookie and Candy in One

Thanks for Sharing!

Today I’ve got one of our favorite Valentine’s Cookies ~  Cookie and Candy in One to share with you. We’ve been making this treat every year since my oldest was in preschool. It’s a candy and a cookie all in one and so pretty too as it’s heart-shaped, perfect for Valentine’s Day!

And what could be more delightful than combining two beloved treats into one fabulous creation? That’s right, we’re talking about Valentine Cookie-Candies!

Picture this: a soft, chewy sugar cookie base, with a beautiful hard candy in the inside of the heart sugar cookie. It’s a match made in dessert heaven, guaranteed to make hearts skip a beat. Plus, they’re incredibly fun to make – perfect for a cozy night in or a festive baking session with your loved ones.

Supplies needed for Valentine Cookies

affiliate links for your convenience

• heart shaped cookie cutters in 2 sizes
  • here’s one like mine
• parchment paper
• jolly rancher candies
• sugar cookie dough
• baking sheet

How To Make Valentine Cookie Candy In One

Start with your favorite sugar cookie recipe or store-bought if you want to go with it quickly and easily. You can find my favorite sugar cookie recipe in this post: Easiest and Yummiest Sugar Cookies. If you purchase a store-bought sugar cookie dough make sure to follow the instructions for roll-out sugar cookies, some times you need to add some flour to the dough. Some doughs also suggest that you let it chill before rolling out.

Roll out your dough on a floured surface, and place the large heart-shaped cookie cutter first.

Here’s a heart cookie cutter like the one I use.

Then center the smaller heart in the middle of the larger cookie cutter.

Place your hollowed-out hearts on a cookie sheet. I love using parchment paper when I made cookies… anyone else? Parchment paper definitely makes this cookie work so much easier.

Then place a Jolly Rancher candy in the center. I used just pink and red Jolly Ranchers, but you could use whatever colors you like. Now if you want to be extra fancy you could add some fun sprinkles to the sugar cookie dough before it goes into the oven.

Bake your cookies in the oven at the temperature and time length that your recipe calls for. The Jolly Rancher hard candies melt perfectly, almost creating a stained glass look.

Let them cool for 5 minutes on the parchment paper before moving to a wire rack to finish cooling.

Super cute and super easy… your kiddos will love these Valentine’s Day Cookies and Candy in One and so will their friends. These cookies make the perfect gift for Valentine’s Day Treats.

You can store the cookies in an airtight container for up to a week.